McAteer surpasses 10,000 career passing yards as Collinsville outlasts Lexington

Collinsville’s Mason McAteer attempts to throw a pass against Lexington in Class 2A state quarterfinal football action on Friday night. Photo by Shannon Fagan.

By Shannon Fagan, WEIS Sports Director

COLLINSVILLE – The Collinsville Panthers have been cardiac cats the past two weeks in the Class 2A state playoffs against Lamar County and Piedmont. Those two nail-biting games were decided by a total of four points.

The Panthers found themselves involved in another close contest against visiting Lexington in the state quarterfinals on Friday night.

But just like the previous two weeks, the Panthers found a way, and now they’re a win away from playing for a state championship.

Senior quarterback Mason McAteer accounted for six touchdowns and surpassed 10,000 career passing yards as Collinsville held off Lexington 44-41 in a state quarterfinal thriller.

After four consecutive seasons of first-round playoff exits, the Panthers are finally headed to the state semifinals for the first time since 2019.

Collinsville (11-2) will travel to Gordo (12-1) next Friday night with a berth in the Class 2A state championship game in Mobile on the line. Gordo advanced with a 21-7 victory over Fyffe.

McAteer completed 21-of-32 pass attempts for 325 yards and three touchdowns. He also rushed 25 times for 85 yards and three scores.

The career passing milestone was another memorable moment for the Collinsville quarterback, who has been the Panthers’ starter since eighth grade.

“I just have to give it all to my coaches, my receivers for sure, and my linemen for sure,” McAteer said. “They did a great job blocking, catching the ball, getting open. I’ve just got to get the ball to them.”

Collinsville coach Ernie Willingham said McAteer’s development over the years has been special to watch.

“He’s been the starter since he’s been in the eighth grade. He played a couple of games in the seventh grade,” Willingham said. “He’s gotten better and better and better. He’s so poised and is such a good teammate. I’m proud of him. He’s my grandson and I’m proud of him for that, but I’m proud of him because he’s such a good boy. He makes everybody around him better.”

The Panthers built a 16-7 lead by the end of the first quarter on a McAteer 51-yard touchdown pass to Gavin Lang and a 12-yard touchdown toss to Kyler Beene.

After Lexington quarterback Zane Kilburn connected with Avery Clark on a 66-yard touchdown to make it a 14-7 game. Collinsville added a safety on a holding penalty with 1:12 remaining in the first quarter to push its lead to 16-7.

McAteer ran for a 7-yard score to push the Panthers out in front 23-7 early in the second quarter, but the Golden Bears got back in the game on a 14-play, 61-yard drive in which Sawyer Howard scored on a 3-yard run. Kilburn’s 2-point conversion pass was intercepted by the Panthers’ Logan Hanson, keeping the score at 23-13 with 3:22 remaining in the first half.

The Panthers used a bit a trickery on their next possession for a touchdown. McAteer completed a pass to Noah Johnson, who then flipped it back to Sylas Adams for a 16-yard touchdown. Uriel Cornejo’s extra point provided the Panthers a 30-13 edge at halftime.

McAteer said the Panthers had worked on the hook-and-ladder play throughout the week.

“Coach felt like it was the right time. It worked perfect,” he said.

Willingham credited offensive coordinator Jon Tidmore for recognizing the opportunity.

“Coach Tidmore is a great offensive coordinator,” Willingham said. “Their corners were playing hard. We completed some short stuff on them, and their corners were coming up hard. We had to get it off. We knew it was going to spring if we got it off.”

Lexington (11-2), however, didn’t back down.

The Golden Bears’ Avery Clark blocked a Collinsville punt to give Lexington the ball at the Panther 30-yard line. Four plays later, Sawyer Howard scored on a 4-yard run. The try for two failed, keeping the score at 30-19.

Collinsville answered with McAteer’s 39-yard touchdown run on its ensuing drive. Following Cornejo’s extra point, the Panthers held a 37-19 lead with 3:55 remaining in the third quarter.

Lexington responded on Kilburn’s 3-yard touchdown run. His ensuing 2-point pass to Buck Shook closed the Panther lead to 37-27 after three quarters.

The Golden Bears crept closer following a Collinsville punt. Clark took a pitch from Kilburn and scooted six yards for a touchdown. The extra point pulled Lexington within three at 37-34.

Dnesperately eeding a big play to regain momentum, the Panthers found it quickly when McAteer connected with Lang on a 42-yard strike. Five plays later, McAteer ran it in from three yards, putting Collinsville back up 10 at 44-34 with 2:11 to go in the game.

“We just felt like we had an advantage on them,” McAteer said on the 42-yard strike to Lang. “We felt like my guy could beat their guy.”

“We wanted to start off that drive with a big play. Right after that we settled down, started running the ball, and we just punched it in right at the end.”

Willingham said the Panthers debated whether to run the football and work the clock or take a chance through the air to Lang.

“We were talking about whether we were going to throw it or run it to try and run the clock out,” Willingham said. “We thought we couldn’t run it, so we threw a long pass and then we just gave the ball to him (McAteer). We just said we’re going to block them down and kick somebody out and find a gap and get in there.”

McAteer credited his offensive line and teammates for opening the way on his touchdown run.

“Somebody led it for me. Everybody was blocking and I just ran it in. I wasn’t even touched,” he said. “My guys did a great job blocking right there.”

Down 10 with 2:11 remaining, Lexington still didn’t back down. Kilburn guided the Golden Bears on an 8-play, 70-yard drive capped off by his 7-yard scoring run. The extra point cut Collinsville’s lead back to three at 44-41 with 1:06 left on the clock.

The Panthers recovered Lexington’s ensuing onside kick and ran out the clock to preserve the victory.

Willingham singled out sophomore Parker Jones for making the recovery.

“My little 10th grade dude (Jones) did a good job picking up that onside kick,” he said.

Like McAteer did against Lexington, Kilburn made things difficult for the Panthers throughout the night. He completed 17-of-32 passes for 244 yards and a touchdown while rushing 16 times for 138 yards and two scores.

Clark added 63 rushing yards and a touchdown on nine carries while catching four passes for 77 yards and another score. Howard had 55 yards and two touchdowns on 12 carries, while Shook hauled in seven passes for 137 yards.

Despite the back-and-forth game, Willingham said his team’s chemistry and willingness to play for one another have been instrumental in its postseason success.

“Our kids have been to the playoffs every year, and these guys have been looking to move on,” Willingham said. “They work really hard and they love each other. They’re just not going to lose when it comes right down to it. Whatever they’ve got to do to win they do.”

McAteer echoed those sentiments.

“Since the eighth grade we’ve been put out in the first round. We’ve been playing since we were seven on field. We just have so much chemistry,” he said.

The Panthers will now turn their attention to Gordo, which defeated Fyffe 21-7 to earn its semifinal spot.

Willingham expects a physical challenge from the Green Wave.

“They’re going to try and beat us up. They’re going to run it every play,” he said. “We’re going to have to buckle up and go. We need all our big guys against them for the way they’re going to play.”

For Collinsville, the opportunity to practice during Thanksgiving week is something the players and coaches have been working toward for years.

Now they finally have that opportunity.

“That’s a privilege to be practicing on Thanksgiving week,” Willingham said. “I’m tickled to death.”

McAteer is looking forward to the opportunity, too.

“It’s the first time for me (playing Thanksgiving Friday). I’m just ready to eat some Thanksgiving food with my guys in the field house,” he said.

The Panthers will also have a little extra motivation against Gordo. McAteer recalled facing the Green Wave in the state baseball playoffs, where Gordo eliminated Collinsville the past two years.

“I’m looking forward to playing them in football,” he said.

Collinsville’s Kyler Beene returns a kickoff for a big gain against Lexington on Friday night. Photo by Shannon Fagan.

Download the WEIS Radio app in the Apple App Store and Google Play Store or subscribe to our text alerts here.